| 1) While everyone seems to be sick and tired of Hollywood teen flicks,Indonesia churns out one which is top-notch. I’m Malaysian, and BahasaIndonesia is pretty different from Bahasa Malaysia although they’resupposedly almost identical. I watched it in the cinema so there weresubtitles, which helped a lot.
This is one teen flick that you’ll regret you didn’t take the time towatch. It revolves around average people leading average lives, whichmakes it so easy to relate to. It tells a story of the choices you’veto make in your life. Choosing your friends or your boyfriend. Manypeople are faced with this challenge in life, and this movieexcellently portrays Cinta’s (Love; the girl’s name) social life(involving her four best friends) and the boy whom she fell in lovewith.
She has two choices to make–choose her friends, or Rangga (the boy).She finally has to make this decision one day when Alya (who seems tobe in a terrible state), her best friend, calls her and asks her outjust when she’s about to go and see Rangga.
What makes this movie so memorable, so beautiful is that it is no wherenear shallow. It revolves around the problems that plague teenagersaround the world today, as well as political problems that manycountries currently face. It also promotes "karya sastera", orliterature, and poetry as well as music amongst teenagers. After all,it is literature that brings Cinta and Rangga together.
I watched this movie over and over, and each time I walked out of thecinema feeling strangely elated. "Ada Apa Dengan Cinta?" reminds you ofhow it was like being young and innocent and free. It reminds you ofthe beauty of young love, and the importance of friends. It reminds youof how the strangest circumstances can bring people together and forgea bond so tight that not even distance would never be able to separatethem.
2) WARNING – SPOILERS BELOW!
Cinta (whose name means "love") is a girl at high school in the wealthyJakarta suburb of Swirijaya Golf. She and her four girlfriends – Maura,Alia, Karmen and Milly – do everything together, both socially and atschool. Cinta has a boyfriend, Borne, but has no real feelings for him.Cinta also writes poetry, and the other four girls are sure she will win theschool poetry competition. But the prize goes instead to a moody loner,Rangga. Partly out of jealousy, Cinta decides to interview him for theschool paper, but Rangga wants no part of it. He didn’t even enter thecompetition – it was his only friend, the school caretaker Mr Wardiman, whoentered one of Rangga’s poems on his behalf. Though neither Cinta nor Ranggawants to admit it, they click. Cinta begins to turn up late, or not at all,for dates with her girlfriends. Without telling them, she is seeing Rangga.Their first date ends badly when they argue and she storms out of asecond-hand book dealer’s, where they have gone on the pretext of trackingdown an out-of-print novel. Borne gets to hear about it and brings some ofhis friends to confront Rangga. They beat him up, but this only brings Cintaand Rangga back together. Cinta gets a glimpse outside her privileged worldwhen she meets Yusrizal, Rangga’s father, who is an academic. For exposinggovernment corruption in 1996, he was fired and persecuted, and evendeserted by his wife and all his children except for Rangga. Cinta is justasking him "But hasn’t there been reform now?" when thugs on motorbikes tossfirebombs through the window. Yusrizal puts out the fires as if it’s aneveryday occurrence and Rangga tell Cinta that it’s no use making acomplaint because "no action will be taken." Later Cinta accepts Rangga’sinvitation to the Blues Cafe, where Rangga’s cousin Rama is a singer. Ramainvites her to perform and she recites Rangga’s winning poem. But when shegets home, her parents are on their way to hospital. Cinta’s friend Alia hasattempted suicide after suffering years of violence at the hands of herfather. Cinta blames herself because she had chosen to go out with Ranggainstead of seeing Alia. The other girls turn on her, and she turns onRangga. But Alia recovers and the girls see their mistake. They realise thatCinta loves Rangga, and urge her to make it up with him. Then they hear fromMr Wardiman that Rangga is leaving to study in New York. The girlscommandeer the car of the school nerd, Mamet, and rush to the airport, whereCinta and Rangga are reconciled. He still has to go to New York, but heleaves her his book of poems, in which he promises to come back toher.
3) After seeing this movie for the second time, I must admit: My oppinion aboutthis movie changed completely.This movie tells the story about 5 girls, heart to heart friends, who sharetheir most inner secrets.This friendship gets damaged when one of the girls (Cinta) falls in lovewith a handsome, sometimes cool, classmate (Rangga) and she keeps thissecret for herself.Their love gets tested when one of the girls ends up in the hospital afterCinta ignores her phonecall due to her date with Rangga.The girls get back together and Cinta and Rangga? To know the answer youHAVE to wathc this movie.
This movie is unlike other Indonesian movies, a film from this millenium.The world of (upperclass) Indonesian teenagers (expensive houses, their ownrooms with stereo, driving cars), but the average teenager from Indonesiarecognizes him/herself in this drama.Comments and sighs are heard throughout the whole movie, and when the timesseem to come that the two young lovers are going to kiss, the whole audienceparticipates and encourages them. Before the kiss comes though, they have towait a long time…
Picture, sound, music, acting, it all shows that Indonesian filmmakers areon the move, and that somehow the time for Hollywood isover.Films from Indonesia, Asia, new Zealand and Uk are doing better than moviesfrom the USA, and the Asian audience as well as many westerners discoverthat there is more than Hollywood.hopefully the time comes that Indonesian movies get recognition by theinternational audience and that the films made in Bollywood get the samequality as this little jewel from Indonesia.Thumbs up for this teenage drama!!!
4) Rather than use "What’s Up with Love?" as the English translation tothe title, I would have used "What is it about Love?". Certainly, theplot is basically about two teenagers experiencing those roller-coasteremotions that come with the first yearnings of love/mutual attraction.They find themselves behaving quite unlike their usual selves, and itmakes them stop and ask the question "What is it about love?". (Ofcourse, it ties in nicely that the female protagonist’s name is Cinta,which is "love" in Indonesian).
The plot is universal enough for anyone to relate to. So the realattraction of this movie lies in the strong script, the good shots usedand the ability of the young actors to interact with each otheron-screen. They don’t seem camera-conscious and they aren’t given awfullines or skimpy clothes that seem to be standard stuff in teen movies.
I’m jaded when it comes to watching teen movies (in fact I hardlybother with them now that I’m not a teen) but this one I really liked.Cinta’s school friends certainly remind me of the friends I had inschool, so it was pretty realistic to me.
What ties it all together is the clever use of an awesome soundtrackwith all original songs written by the brilliant Melly Goeslaw. Themusic itself can tell the story, and that says a lot for it.
There are weak moments, as there are in most movies. But nothing I’vecringed at, or anything I care to remember. I cannot understand much ofthe Indonesian language and yet the movie spoke to me, so I give it mythumbs up.
5) Well, I only have a chance to watch this film on VCD because I don’t havemuch courage to go to theatre and have to deal with thoseteenagers…Speaking about age, right??This is absolutely the best Indonesian film on the last three years… Iwatched Pasir Berbisik with Dian Sastro on it as well, but I have to saythat A2DC is far more better. Not pretentious to be ‘art’ film like PasirBerbisik of course, but it is believable and somehow get me hooked into thestory….Dian Sastro should be ranked as Indonesia Sweetheart of this days…Not tocompare with those beauty no-brain on sinetron (tv show) who just mumblethrough the whole episodes without much depth exploration…!!!
Kudos to all of the casts and crews…Yet, I don’t know that Mang Diman hasalready passed away until I watched the last credit…*Sigh*
6) It’s a local champ, and can be a very entertaining teen flick worldwide.Real characters fill this high-school love movie. The script smoothlyrunsthe story, and strongly constructs the whole first love theme. Thelove-and-hate chemistry between the main characters works very well too.Actually, the scene where Rangga (the guy, Nicholas Saputra) dropped hisprecious book in Cinta (the girl, Dian Sastro) is too much of acoincidence… and simply the easiest way to move the story forward. Stillacceptable,though. Supporting actress Ladya Cheryll (as Alya, Cinta’s friend)deliversa very natural screen-stealing performance. Good music, good faces, goodending too. Overall, this is the kind of movie for a date, for a lazySundayafternoon, and for all time.
7) Ada Apa Dengan Cinta? What is wrong with love? that’s a good questionafterhaving seen this movie.The movie never really becomes interesting for the intelligent audience.Itis a story about love yes, but nothing special when you compare it to allthe awful cinetron’s (local soaps) that haunts the Indonesian televisionstations. "Ada apa dengan cinta" is just a soap for the cinema, and itdoesatract mostly teenagers.Well, it is actually about teenage love, and most teens who watch thismoviethink it is a movie in western style, different from the local Indonesianblockbusters.The actors however are really acting like amateurs, the story never getsreally exiting, although the screams of some teenagers during the moviemakeyou think you are watching a drama like "Shakespeare in love". Indonesianteenagers scream at any movie… For me it was very boring, although thepicture and sound quality are much better than most Indonesian movies Ihaveseen so far.I am not going to say that you should not see it, you have to judge foryourself, like you have to do with every movie. But if you expectsomethingspecial from Indonesia that will perform well on the internationalfilmfestivals, you’ve got it wrong. For that, Indonesian actors will needmore training (especially their way of talking is overdramatic), and theIndonesian filmindustry will need more funds.Maybe the succes of movies like "Jelangkung" and "Ada apa dengan cinta?"will bring financial resources to make something more beautyfull?
All you really need is one book that you don't have to be clean tohold!
So being about linguistics, is that Sophie Marceau is still lost in afrench jungle. We will still take the guy who 'tick him off, to theback, beat him up, and sue the editor for all the Star Newspaper isworth.
In America, they do it, 'for Why Let It Slide??' We'll do it, not toshow face!! And we'll go ALL THE WAY!
i LIED, they'didn't make a Rambo III.
And I'LL DO IT AGAIN! FOR My cousin!
shafique
9) I must admit that AADC is a movie in my guilty enjoyment list. The onlyreason why I watched it was because I liked its soundtracks that was onheavy airplay on MTV and couldn’t help but catch glimpses of thecuriosity-arousing scenes. And I must say, I was not disappointed.
I appreciate the elements in this movie that make it so different fromthe typical soap-ish Indonesian movie… the fact Cinta and Rangga’sinterests were rare classical Indonesian literature, the contrastingbackgrounds of Cinta and Rangga, the school fights, the bomb threats,the goofy humour juxtaposed with scenes that are cold and serious, anda dose of romance that was just right.
However, I am mostly grateful for the attitudes Rangga & Cinta decidedto have in the end–sticking to their priorities and embracing them byplacing their faith in the unknown rather than succumbing to thefairytale-ish pressure to give up their dreams "in the name of love".When Rangga said "I must go," I literally applauded. I just loveopen-ended, realistic stories that encourage its watchers that it’sokay to let go of love and be broken hearted for awhile–in the end youwill not regret sticking to your priorities rather. It’s about time westop making movies that promote sacrificing one’s future in order to bewith one’s object of infatuation whose true love is not yettested–such as the case with The Prince and Me (starring Julia Stilesand Luke Mably). I was fuming mad when Prince Edvard showed up atPaige’s graduation and wooed her to go back to Denmark with him–whatabout her future with Doctors Without Borders??? I am proud that ascreenwriter from my country (reputable for the most horrible soapoperas in case you don’t know) knows better than that.
The on-screen kiss was good… chapeau to the director who dared toincorporate it and create the controversy as the first silver-screenIndonesian movie featuring the kiss!
I’m quite curious how this movie would feel like in Japanese. By theway, why is it called "Beautiful Days" there, and how would theJapanese audience understand the context of classical Indonesianliterature, for instance? (even in Indonesia one rarely finds ateenager who’s familiar with the stuff Rangga reads… but at leastthey’d have previous exposure to some national literature)
Anyway, back to Ada Apa Dengan Cinta, everything was very wellcoordinated–great storyline, excellent choice of actors, fabulousmusical soundtrack, and chapeau to Rudi Soedjarwo for daring to goagainst the conventional!
10) I enjoyed AAD2? and found it had the general stuff like most Hollywoodteen flicks; friendship, teen angst, independence, love and comedy,like any shallow person I enjoyed the comedy/romance at the end betweenCinta and her friends getting to the airport to get to Rangga before heleft and then leaving without Mamet.
However I also liked the undertones of societal issues such as domesticviolence leading to despair and attempted suicide. The issue ofpolitical beliefs which resulted in loss of status and in Rangga’s casefamily members who left. These types of issues are not usually found ina Hollywood teen flick and I think this is a movie that Indonesiashould be proud of. |