The Adventures of Gerard
| Title: | The Adventures of Gerard |
| Year: | 1970 |
| Directors: | Jerzy Skolimowski |
| Writers: | H.A.L. Craig (writer) Arthur Conan Doyle (story) |
| Actors: | Peter McEnery | Claudia Cardinale | Eli Wallach | Jack Hawkins | Mark Burns | Norman Rossington | John Neville | Paolo Stoppa | Ivan Desny | Leopoldo Trieste | Solvi Stubing | John Bartha | Aude Loring |
| Rating: | 4.6 | 70 votes |
| Languages: | English |
| Color: | Color |
| Country: | UK | Switzerland |
| Company: | Sir Nigel Films |
| Genres: | Adventure | Comedy |
| Comments: | |
| 1) I was pleasantly surprised by this one: Leonard Maltin rates it a BOMBbut I found it great fun, if uneven. Skolimowski's firstEnglish-language film was actually shot in Cinecitta' and, in fact,features many Italians in the cast (all of whom struggle with theliterary – and very English – nature of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle'soriginal!).
There's still plenty of amusing detail to savor – the subject matter ofthe Napoleonic Wars is treated as farce most of the time and, in fact,there's quite a bit of slapstick involved (to which Skolimowski'stechnique is happy to oblige via numerous camera tricks, pretty muchthe sole link here to his early Polish films) – and, accordingly, allthe performances are broadly delineated: Peter McEnery is a pompous yetlikable ne'er-do-well hero; Eli Wallach is a buffoonish (and gay)Napoleon; while Jack Hawkins has a whale of a time (which, alas,happened very seldom in the films he made following the tragic loss ofhis voice) as the flustered leader of a bandit rabble who have adoptednovel means of torture and execution, and are even dressed in Klan-typegarb! Apart from asides to the audience, McEnery also engages in a constantlyinterrupted duel with British officer Mark Burns – with whom he alsospars for the affections of beautiful and fiery Spanish countessClaudia Cardinale. John Neville is the Duke of Wellington in his lastfilm for almost 20 years (when he achieved some latter-day notoriety,in another tongue-in-cheek fantasia no less, with the title role ofTerry Gilliam's THE ADVENTURES OF BARON MUNCHAUSEN [1988]). RizOrtolani contributes a suitably jaunty, yet frequently rousing, score. Unfortunately, some of the film's visual impact was inevitably lost inthe pan-and-scan version I watched (taped off Cable TV); originallyshot in Panavision, I wouldn't mind owning this in its proper AspectRatio on DVD… 2) I saw this movie this morning and I must say it does not deserve one star.Iadmit, this movie is not exactly a CLASSIC per se but it has its share offunny moments. I’m not much of a fan of OLD movies but this one has charmtoit. You have the lovely Claudia Cardinale of ‘Once Upon a Time in theWest’fame and Eli Wallach in this movie…good cast and an alrightmovie. It’s supposed to be an adventure/comedy and sees to be more alongside thegenre of Comedy more than anything. It’s funny but not downright hilariousin parts and the adventure seems more comical than serious. Eh, not bad. **+/**** 3) I don't think this movie is much to get excited about either but Idon't agree that the "easily entertained" are stupid or that theyshould be "ignored" because of some perception of same, valid or no. Ialso think that when being dictatorial rather than critical which isthe proper tone for a review, one should know the difference in meaningbetween "fitfully" and "fittingly." When it comes to stupidity, let hewho is without etc…. I have seen more than one film which I thoughtwas "stupid" but rarely do I think that people who disagree with myopinion are "stupid" simply because they like something I don't. I amalso uncomfortable with the notion that their right to be entertainedis predicated on their personal taste. 4) I've only seen half this film on late-night TV so I can't be sure ifit's really good or not. The bit I did see was charming. McEnery isfabulous as the Conan-Doyle hero, Cardinale is as lovely as ever andEli Wallach hams beautifully. There's lots of running about deserty parts of Spain and amusing asidesto the camera by Gerard, including the perfect way to get your bootsoff. There are also very weirdly filmed (and plain weird) sequences that putthis film far above other silly 1960s "romp films" (is that a genre?).The best example is a stunning slow-mo bit where a bandit with his headpopping up in the middle of table is killed William Tell fashion by hispreposterously debonair chief. I'd love to see the rest but it hasn't got a DVD release (I don't thinkit even had a VHS release) and is very rarely screened on telly. Likeat lot of Euro-productions, it's uneven, often badly dubbed and wasprobably panned at the time, with most people involved having forgottenabout it (or trying to forget about it). Perhaps it's a great"undiscovered" comedy film. It's at least worthy of a bit moreattention. And what happened to Peter McEnery? He was great in this and as MrSloane. The results on this site show he's been condemned to TVmini-series for 25 years. 5) The Adventures of Gerard is a somewhat silly romp set during theNapoleonic era featuring that career-went-nowhere semi-sexy Brit PeterMcEnery. McEnery is exceptionally handsome in a rakish kind of way –in this movie, he always looks slightly unclean, like a 1970s pornstar, sporting as he does the cheesiest of mustaches. But he keeps atwinkle in his eye, and his physical comedy is well-polished. He has areally nice body from the waist up, but the skinniness of his legs isreinforced by the military uniforms he wears in this movie, which areextraordinarily high-waisted. McEnery as Gerard plays some kind of messenger, a low-ranking Frenchofficer ferrying missives among the regiments of the French armyoccupying Spain. Hilarity ensues, mostly involving Claudia Cardinale asa sexy Spanish lass doing her best Sophia Loren imitation, with poutylips and unkempt tresses. At one point, she is (thinly) disguised as aboy, but McEnery sees through her disguise (how could he not?!) andproceeds to seduce her (how could he?!). See what I mean about hilarityensuing? Spain itself looks like the Old West as envisioned by SergioLeone. And the movie will win no Oscars for Sound Effects Editing. Iswear you can visualize the sound guys clapping coconuts together inthe booth, timing their clangings to the fourfold footfalls of theequine cast. This is a fun film. With its tongue-and-cheek dialog ("The Emperorhimself approved my mustache!"), none-too-subtle sex humor, vigorousvisual gags, hairbreadth escapes and coincidences, broad stereotypes(the English and their tea! and there is a whole fox-hunting sequence),and the time-honored technique of directly addressing the camera (whichis a technique I like, when done well, which it is here), it is agenuine hoot. And McEnery has a subtlety about him. He can do a lotwith a twist of his mustache or a raised eyebrow. He does sexy-stupidreally well. Look for that all-purpose ethnic Eli Wallach as Napoleon. 6) Except for the easily entertained, who should always be ignored fortheir obvious stupidity, this film is a lumbering bore. McEnery issaddled with the hideously written title character who annoys one andall from the first scene to the last. He is that old standby: theoblivious vainglorious military schmuck. The adventures he engages inare more like antics, with lots of frantic activity in a vain attemptto provide humor. But Gerard is such an unwavering clod that he becomestiresome very quickly, yet you're stuck with him until the end of thisfiasco (that is if you decide to keep watching). Cardinale is quitefetching, as always, and Wallach tries as Napoleon, but the script letsthem all down. The story is some dull nonsense about Napoleon in needof an idiot officer to bring a false dispatch to the enemy to wreakhavoc. Gerard gets the thankless job but becomes an unexpected hero asthe story unwinds. Quite predictable. It all takes place duringNapoleon's war in Spain, but this is NOT something to look at if you'rea fan of the 'Sharpe' series by Cornwell that takes place in the samevenue. This film was barely released, deservedly, and remains fitfullyburied to this day. Hopefully no where near Conan Doyle's final restingplace. |
|